The Ultimate Showdown: Toaster Ovens vs Air Fryers

As convenience appliances for the home kitchen continue to evolve, people are increasingly turning to toaster ovens and air fryers to help them save time and energy. 

While toaster ovens have been around for decades, air fryers have become increasingly popular in recent years. Whether you’re a novice in the kitchen or a seasoned pro, it can be difficult to decide which of these two appliances is right for you. 

In this article, we will compare the features and benefits of toaster ovens and air fryers to help you make the best decision for your cooking needs.

Toaster ovens use both convection and radiant heat to cook food. This means the heat radiates from both the top and bottom of the oven, allowing for more even cooking. Air fryers, on the other hand, use hot air that circulates around the food to cook it. This method is much faster than a toaster oven, so you can get your food done quicker.

Now let’s take a closer look at toasters and air fryers, to see which one fits your needs the most.

What Are the Disadvantages of a Toaster Oven?

A toaster oven is a convenient kitchen appliance that allows you to quickly and easily heat up food. However, there are some downsides to using a toaster oven that you should be aware of. 

First, toaster ovens are often much bigger than traditional toasters, so you may need to clear some counter space to accommodate one. Additionally, toaster ovens use more energy than traditional toasters, so they can increase your monthly electric bill.

Second, toaster ovens can be difficult to clean. The crumbs and grease from cooking can easily accumulate in the crevices of the toaster oven, making it difficult to remove. If you don’t clean the toaster oven regularly, it can start to smell and attract pests. Third, toaster ovens can be hazardous to use. 

The heating elements can get very hot, and it is easy to burn yourself if you are not careful. Additionally, some toaster ovens do not have a timer, so you need to keep an eye on the food to ensure it does not overcook, I have definitely had this problem with past toaster ovens! 

Finally, toaster ovens are more expensive than traditional toasters. Toaster ovens work by using multiple types of technology from the use of heat, convection, radiation, and conduction.

Example of a toaster oven.

Is a Toaster Oven Worth It?

It depends on your needs and preferences. Toaster ovens are great for those who need or prefer a small and compact cooking appliance, as they provide many of the same features and benefits of a conventional oven but in a much smaller size. 

They are also generally more energy-efficient than traditional ovens, making them a great choice for those looking to save on energy costs.

Toaster Oven Specs

Now let’s look at some of the specs of toaster ovens.

Size20x12x9 inches
Weight12.3 lbs
Temperature Range150°F to 500°F
Timer30 minutes
Number of Rack Positions2

Toaster ovens are a convenient way to cook things and crisp things up!

Air Fryer Vs Toaster Oven Cooking Times

Both of these forms of cooking have different cooking times. Generally, the air fryer is much faster at cooking. Let’s take a closer look.

Air Fryer:

  • Frozen French Fries: 10-15 minutes
  • Fish Fillets: 10-14 minutes
  • Chicken Nuggets: 8-10 minutes
  • Tofu: 8-10 minutes

Toaster Oven:

  • Frozen French Fries: 15-20 minutes
  • Fish Fillets: 12-15 minutes
  • Chicken Nuggets: 10-12 minutes
  • Tofu: 10-12 minutes

Either way, you’re going to get fast-cooked food that is delicious, hot, and ready to serve!

Air Fryer Specs

Now let’s look at some of the specs of the air fryer. Air fryers use a little more energy but they get the job done quicker!

Capacity2-4 quarts
Temperature Range180°F to 400°F
TimerUp to 30 minutes
Power1200-1800 watts
FeaturesAdjustable temperature and timer, removable basket, auto shut-off

Air Fryer vs Toaster Oven: Which is the More Energy-Efficient Option

When it comes to kitchen appliances, one of the most important factors to consider is electricity consumption. The two most popular kitchen appliances for cooking are air fryers and toaster ovens. 

Both of these appliances are great for cooking a variety of foods, but which one is more efficient when it comes to electricity consumption? 

Air fryers are becoming increasingly popular due to their ability to cook food quickly and with minimal oil. They require less electricity than traditional ovens. Air fryers typically use around 1,500 watts of electricity, which is significantly less than a traditional oven. They primarily use convection technology.

Toaster ovens are also becoming more popular due to their versatility. They can be used to bake, toast, and even broil food. Toaster ovens typically use around 1,200 watts of electricity, which is slightly less than an air fryer. 

When it comes to electricity consumption, both air fryers and toaster ovens are relatively efficient. However, air fryers use slightly more electricity than toaster ovens. This is because air fryers require more power to generate the hot air needed to cook food. 

Overall, both air fryers and toaster ovens are great options for cooking food quickly and efficiently. However, if you’re looking for the most efficient option when it comes to electricity consumption, then a toaster oven is the way to go.

Air Fryer vs Convection Toaster Oven: What’s the Difference?

While both appliances can be used to cook food, there are some key differences between the two that should be considered before deciding which one, if not both, is right for your kitchen.

The air fryer is a relatively new kitchen appliance that uses hot air to cook food. It works by circulating hot air around the food, which cooks it quickly and evenly. The air fryer is great for making crispy foods like french fries and chicken wings, as well as other dishes like roasted vegetables. 

The main advantage of an air fryer is that it uses significantly less oil than traditional frying methods, making it a healthier option.

On the other hand, a convection toaster oven uses both hot air and heat to cook food. It works by circulating hot air around the food, while also using infrared heat to cook the food from the outside in. This type of oven is great for baking and roasting, as the hot air helps to evenly cook the food. 

The convection toaster oven is also great for making toast, as it can evenly brown the bread without burning it. 

Example of an Air Fryer | Toaster Oven vs Air Fryer.

Don’t Get Fried! The Disadvantages of Air Fryers You Should Know

Air fryers have become increasingly popular in recent years, as they offer a healthier alternative to deep frying. However, as with any kitchen appliance, there are some drawbacks to using an air fryer. 

Here are some of the disadvantages of air fryers. 

1. Limited Capacity: Air fryers are typically smaller than traditional deep fryers, meaning they can only cook a limited amount of food at one time. This can be inconvenient if you’re trying to cook a large meal for a family or group of friends. 

2. Expensive: Air fryers can be quite expensive, especially when compared to traditional deep fryers and toaster ovens. This can be a major deterrent for those who are on a budget. 

3. Long Cooking Times: Air fryers can take longer to cook food than traditional deep fryers, which can be inconvenient if you’re in a hurry. 

4. Messy: Air fryers can create a lot of mess, as the hot air and oil can splatter all over the inside of the container. This can be a hassle to clean up. 

5. Limited Variety: Air fryers are limited in the types of food they can cook. They are not suitable for cooking things like freshly coated items to be fried. They come out dry and dusty because they do not have the oil to saturate them. 

Overall, air fryers can be a great way to cook healthier meals. However, they do have some drawbacks that should be taken into consideration.

Toaster Oven vs Air Fryer Pros and Cons

Here are a few of the pros and cons when comparing these two kitchen appliances. Each one has benefits and each one has a few drawbacks.

Air FryerToaster Oven
  • Uses less oil than traditional frying
  • Faster cooking time
  • Easy to use and clean
  • Can cook a variety of foods
  • More energy efficient than a regular oven
  • Can be used to toast, bake, and broil
  • Smaller capacity than a traditional oven
  • Food can easily burn if not monitored
  • Fewer options on what to cook
  • Limited capacity
  • Food can easily burn if not monitored
  • Not as energy efficient as an air fryer

Can You Put Aluminum Foil in an Air Fryer?

Air fryers are a great way to make delicious, healthy meals without the added fat of deep-frying. But can you put aluminum foil in an air fryer? The answer is yes, you can use aluminum foil in an air fryer. 

Aluminum foil can be used to line the air fryer basket or tray to make clean-up easier. It can also be used to wrap food, such as potatoes or fish, to help them cook more evenly. However, it’s important to note that aluminum foil should never touch the heating element of the air fryer. Doing so can cause a fire hazard. 

When using aluminum foil in an air fryer, it’s important to use the right type. Heavy-duty aluminum foil is best, as it won’t tear or puncture easily. 

Did you know you can cook fish in an air fryer? Check out our article on Salmon Vs Tilapia

When wrapping food in aluminum foil, it’s important to leave some space between the food and the foil. This will help ensure that the food cooks evenly and that the foil doesn’t get too hot. You should not completely cover the sides of the basket with foil because the air needs to circulate through those holes and it’s important to remember to remove the aluminum foil after cooking. 

The Final Word

When it comes to deciding which appliance is best for you, it really depends on what type of cooking you plan to do. When I first got my air fryer, I almost threw away my toaster oven! 

Luckily for me, I did not throw it away because the toaster oven has many uses that still make it more convenient than the air fryer in certain situations.

If you’re looking for a healthier option that can make crispy foods quickly, then an air fryer is the way to go. However, if you’re looking for an appliance that can make toast and bake or roast food, then a convection toaster oven is the better option. 

For me, they both have a place in my kitchen.